Afraid to close her eyes for fear of falling asleep, she aligned her posture and looked out the window. Recognizing where she was, Catherine adjusted her scarf tighter around her neck, put on her gloves, stood up and walked to the front of the bus, her stop was coming up.
Exiting the bus she turned left and walked north on Huntington Ave. Crossing the street she entered the Quick Stop Coffee Shop for her nightly Cappuccino.
“Hey Sister Catherine how’s it going? Want the usual?” The young woman behind the counter asked.
“How many times Claire, do I have to tell you, I’m not a Nun anymore?
“Sorry, forget every time… how long has it been?
“Two years next month, please call me Catherine, just plain Catherine.”
“You got it! Here’s your cappuccino and I will see you “Catherine” tomorrow.” Then gave her a little wink.
Catherine left the shop and continued her walk home, passing under the bridge that separated Jamaica Plain from Brookline. Taking a left at the high-rise known as The Brook House, she walked the two blocks to Juniper Street and opened the wrought iron gate to #6. She proceeded up the path to the stairs that led up to the porch, turning briefly and looking up at the night sky. “Full moon,” she thought to herself, “there are always happenings during the full moon. Please God let it all end tonight.” Unlocking the front door, she walked up the 3 flights to her apartment. Once inside she put her purse, keys and satchel on the table and immediately walked to the door of the back porch, opening it she ventured out and stood by the wooden railing. The night sky was beautiful, millions of stars were visible and the moon was at its fullest. She loved the view of the Muddy River on clear nights like this. The water seemed to shimmer and moved like the notes of a Chopin Symphony. It was just beautiful.
Looking over the river to the far side, she could see the lights of the recovery team from the State Police.
She prayed aloud, “Please God, end this thing!”
Chapter 2
Catherine Sullivan was born on November 12, 1960. By all accounts her parents abandoned her at birth and she was adopted by loving couple who lived in the Chestnut Hill section of Brookline. They were devoted Catholics and brought Catherine up with the same zeal and devotion.
Catherine appeared to be a perfectly happy and well-adjusted child to those around her, but in her dreams . . . well, let’s just say, she was someone else and suffered from night terrors; horrible, scary dreams in which she did unspeakable things, things, that as a child she knew nothing about nor understood. These happenings, as she always called them, would haunt her through childhood into adolescence, occurring only during the night of the full moon. They abruptly stopped on her 16th birthday.
Upon graduating from Boston College, with a Masters in Psychology, she decided to join the Convent and entered “The Order of the Sacred Heart”. Her life as Sister Catherine Louise was joyous one and in her position as Psychologist for Sacred Heart High School, she found fulfillment. That is, until the night the happenings returned. They were somehow different this time, almost sad, in a strange sort of way and more troubling than frightening. She became more and more obsessed with their meaning, even to the point that Mother Superior questioned whether or not she had chosen the correct vocation and suggested that she take a leave of absence. Knowing that she had to get to the bottom of these occurrences she made the difficult decision to leave the Order
Chapter 3
Her first order of business was to find a place to live. She knew she would like to live in Brookline and preferably an apartment close to the river, Muddy River. Why? She didn’t really know, she just knew that it was important.
After months of disappointed viewings, she found what seemed to be the perfect location, #6 Juniper Street, third floor. The minute she walked inside the small efficiency apartment, she knew this was the one and moved in that weekend.
From the very first night in her new apartment, she found herself continuously tossing and turning and unable to sleep. When she did finally fall asleep, she was tormented by strange and obscure dreams. Much different from the happenings, these dreams were filled faceless men, calling out to her for help, begging her to set them free. Free from what, she had no idea but she felt that somehow this was connected to her birth parents.
For the next year and a half Catherine searched every record and archive available to the public, tracking down and following up every lead that might give an end to the happenings and the new dreams. And every night, those dreams would point her in another direction, another clue, another piece of the puzzle.
It was becoming a very frightening journey of discovery. One that she wished she didn’t have to make.
Chapter 4
Starring at the lights across the river, Catherine was startled by the phone ringing.
“Sister Catherine?”
“Yes, this is Catherine Sullivan.”
“This is Detective Somerset from the Mass. State Police. I’m still not sure exactly how you knew it, but you were correct. I have sent a car to pick you up. WE need to talk!”
“Of course, I’ll be right down. . . Detective Somerset, is it over?”
“I hope so Sister.”
“Please, just call me….” the line went dead.
Chapter 5
Sitting in the interview room of the State Police barracks, Catherine opened up her briefcase and laid out the manila folders in their correct order. Sitting across from her were Detective Somerset and his superior, Captain Ross.
Captain Ross looked straight into the eyes of Catherine.”Shall we get started?” He then turned to the two-way mirror behind him and spoke to whoever was behind it, “You can turn on the video tape now.”
Captain Ross spoke first. “Sister Catherine, Detective Somerset tells me that you contacted him several months ago about some suspicions you had about your birth mother. Is that correct?”
Catherine nodded. “But please call me. . .”
The Captain continued. “And these suspicions were a direct result of dreams?” He dropped his head and looked over his glasses. “Now Sister Catherine, I don’t know if these dreams came to you from the man upstairs, your aunt Suzy or the bogey man, but if you were not a nun and if you were 25 years older, I am afraid I would be charging you with multiple murders.”
“Captain, I understand how absurd this all must sound but I can assure you, it is the truth. I don’t claim to understand the reasons for the dreams, other than to assume they came from desperate spirits yearning to pass over. Souls that called out to God for justice and peace. Not only that but they are there due to the actions of my own birth mother.”
“Now gentlemen, please let me explain the circumstances that resulted in the death of these 5 Men.”
The Detective tried to interrupt but Catherine held up her right hand. “Please, may I continue?”
The Detective conceded and gave a nod.
Catherine took a deep breath and made a silent prayer for guidance and then started her story.
“My birth mothers name was Helen Winston, born in 1938 in Jamaica Plain. She married Frank Watterson in 1954. He was a drunkard and by all accounts, a violent man. He was convicted of killing a man in a bar room brawl in 1957 and sent to Walpole Prison for life. It was at this time, because of desperate circumstances, I believe my mother became a prostitute. She was living on Huntington Ave. at a boarding house for women. Across the street was a place called “Maggie’s Bar” which I believe is where she met her. . . how can I put it . . . men or johns. She would bring them to her room, rob and then murder them, throwing their bodies into the Muddy River, which was directly behind the boarding house.”
The Captain tried to interrupt. “But Sister Catherine. . .”
“Please be patient Captain and let me continue.”
”Her last victim was my father. She had met him several times at the bar, where he would stop on his way home from work. I imagine she took a fancy to him because as a result of this encounter, she became pregnant with me. I was born in 1960 at “The Home for Unwed Mothers” right on Huntington Ave, down the street from where you found the 5 bodies tonight. My mother died in childbirth.”
The Captain interrupted, “Sister Catherine, do you have evidence to these facts?”
Catherine smiled. “Captain, there are no coincidences in life.”The Home for Unwed Mothers” was run by the “Order of the Sacred Heart”, the same order I entered when I became a Nun. They never throw out anything and when my mother came there to live, until I was born, she kept a diary. When she died all her belongings were boxed and stored. All I needed was to talk to my Sisters and offer up my date of birth. It was all in the records.”
Catherine continued, “Now, for the truly bizarre part of the story, my father, who was her 5th and last victim, lived at 6 Juniper St, where I have lived for the last year and a half. There is the hand of God working here.”
The Captain stood up, placed his hands flat on the table and leaned in close to Catherine’s face.
“Sister, you have mentioned 5 men several times. Well I have some bad news for you, as of two hours ago; we have recovered 14 skeletal remains in the Muddy River. It seems that your mother now has the distinction of being the most prolific female serial killer in the State of Massachusetts. And that Sister had nothing to do with God.”
Recent Comments